74. Use the serialization methods writeUnshared() and readUnshared() with care

When objects are serialized using the writeObject() method, each object is written to the output stream only once. Invoking the writeObject() method on the same object a second time places a back-reference to the previously serialized instance in the stream. Correspondingly, the readObject() method produces at most one instance for each object present in the input stream that was previously written by writeObject().

According to the Java API [API 2011], the writeUnshared() method

writes an "unshared" object to the ObjectOutputStream. This method is identical to writeObject, except that it always writes the given object as a new, unique object in the stream (as opposed to a back-reference pointing to a previously serialized instance).

Correspondingly, the readUnshared() method

reads an "unshared" object from the ObjectInputStream. This method is identical to readObject, except that it prevents subsequent calls to readObject and readUnshared from returning additional references to the deserialized instance obtained via this call.

This means that the writeUnshared() and readUnshared() methods should not be used for round-trip serialization of data structures that contain reference cycles. It is also important to note that calls to the writeUnshared() and readUnshared() methods prevent sharing only of the object being serialized. Sharing of objects reached from references in the unshared object remains unchanged.  

Consider the following code example:

public class Person {
  private String name;
    
  Person() {
    // Do nothing - needed for serialization
  }
    
  Person(String theName) {
    name = theName;
  }
 
  // Other details not relevant to this example
}


public class Student extends Person implements Serializable {
  private Professor tutor;
     
  Student() {
    // Do nothing - needed for serialization
  }
     
  Student(String theName, Professor theTutor) {
    super(theName);
    tutor = theTutor;
  }
     
  public Professor getTutor() {
    return tutor;
  }
}
 
public class Professor extends Person implements Serializable {
  private List<Student> tutees = new ArrayList<Student>();
     
  Professor() {
    // Do nothing - needed for serialization
  }
     
  Professor(String theName) {
    super(theName);
  }
     
  public List<Student> getTutees () {
    return tutees;
  }
     
  /**
   * checkTutees checks that all the tutees
   * have this Professor as their tutor
   */
  public boolean checkTutees () {
    boolean result = true;
    for (Student stu: tutees) {
      if (stu.getTutor() != this) {
         result = false;
         break;
      }
    }
    return result;
  }
}

// ...
 
Professor jane = new Professor("Jane");
Student able = new Student("Able", jane);
Student baker = new Student("Baker", jane);
Student charlie = new Student("Charlie", jane);
jane.getTutees().add(able);
jane.getTutees().add(baker);
jane.getTutees().add(charlie);
System.out.println("checkTutees returns: " + jane.checkTutees());
// Prints "checkTutees returns: true"

Professor and Students are types that extend the basic type Person. A student (that is, an object of type Student) has a tutor of type Professor. A professor (that is, an object of type Professor) has a list (actually, an ArrayList) of tutees (of type Student). The method checkTutees() checks whether all of the tutees of this professor have this professor as their tutor, returning true if that is the case and false otherwise. 

Suppose that Professor Jane has three students, Able, Baker, and Charlie, all of whom have Professor Jane as their tutor. Issues can arise if the writeUnshared() and readUnshared() methods are used with these classes, as demonstrated in the following noncompliant code example.

Noncompliant Code Example

This noncompliant code example attempts to serialize the data from the previous example using writeUnshared(). 

String filename = "serial";
try(ObjectOutputStream oos = new ObjectOutputStream(new FileOutputStream(filename))) {
  // Serializing using writeUnshared
  oos.writeUnshared(jane);
} catch (Throwable e) {
  // Handle error
}

// Deserializing using readUnshared
try(ObjectInputStream ois = new ObjectInputStream(new FileInputStream(filename))){
  Professor jane2 = (Professor)ois.readUnshared();
  System.out.println("checkTutees returns: " +
							 jane2.checkTutees());
} catch (Throwable e) {
  // Handle error
}

However, when the data is deserialized using readUnshared(), the checkTutees() method no longer returns true because the tutor objects of the three students are different from the original Professor object.

Compliant Solution

This compliant solution overcomes the problem of the noncompliant code example by using writeObject() and readObject(), ensuring that the tutor object referred to by the three students has a one-to-one mapping with the original Professor object. The checkTutees() method correctly returns true.

String filename = "serial";
try(ObjectOutputStream oos = new ObjectOutputStream(new FileOutputStream(filename))) {
	// Serializing using writeUnshared
	oos.writeObject(jane);
} catch (Throwable e) {
    // Handle error
} 

// Deserializing using readUnshared
try(ObjectInputStream ois = new ObjectInputStream(new FileInputStream(filename))) {
Professor jane2 = (Professor)ois.readObject();
System.out.println("checkTutees returns: " +
					 jane2.checkTutees());
} catch (Throwable e) {
    // Handle error
} 

Applicability

Using the writeUnshared() and readUnshared() methods may produce unexpected results.

Bibliography